District to Present Updated Facility Options at December 3 Board of Education Meeting
Independence Local Schools has continued its work to address the significant facility needs at our primary and middle schools following the unsuccessful bond issue in May 2026. While the election outcome did not change the aging conditions of these buildings or the need for long-term improvements, it provided an important opportunity to listen to our community, reevaluate our approach, and explore alternative solutions that balance educational needs with financial responsibility.
District leadership and the Board of Education have continued discussions about how best to address these challenges while responding to resident feedback. One key consideration emerging from these discussions is the possibility of approaching future facility improvements in phases, prioritizing the most pressing needs while maximizing the use of existing facilities. To support this work, Independence Local Schools continues to partner with Garmann Miller, a local planning and design firm specializing in K-12 educational facilities.
Exploring a Phased Approach to Facility Improvements
A central component of the district's ongoing planning is recognizing the significant facility needs at Independence Primary School and exploring whether to address them as the first phase of a larger, long-term facilities plan.
Rather than pursuing the previously proposed comprehensive PreK-8 building project, the district is now examining the feasibility of constructing a new primary school facility adjacent to Independence Middle School. This approach could allow the district to address the most pressing needs of its youngest learners while preserving and strategically improving portions of the existing middle school.
Another key consideration is retaining and renovating the middle school's auditorium and gymnasium, creating shared-use spaces that could serve both elementary and middle school students. This approach could maximize existing district resources, provide valuable educational and extracurricular opportunities, and potentially reduce the amount of new construction required.
While the primary school may represent the first priority, the district acknowledges that Independence Middle School also has significant facility needs that must be addressed.
As part of the ongoing evaluation, the district is exploring whether targeted renovations and infrastructure improvements could extend the middle school building's useful life for additional years.
Potential improvements under consideration include upgrades to electrical systems, air conditioning and ventilation, replacement of aging windows, roofing improvements, and other critical building systems. Although renovations of this nature represent a substantial financial investment, they may provide an opportunity to preserve portions of the existing building while addressing important safety, comfort, and operational needs.
The district is carefully examining whether these investments would be financially responsible over the long term, particularly when compared with the costs of new construction. This evaluation is essential to determining how the district can best use taxpayer resources while providing high-quality learning environments for students.
Facility Study to Outline Options and Costs
Garmann Miller is evaluating several potential approaches, including new construction for the primary grades, renovating and continuing to use existing middle school spaces, opportunities for shared facilities, and the feasibility of phased improvements. The study is also examining the condition of existing building systems, the functionality of instructional and common spaces, site considerations, traffic patterns, and the potential costs associated with each approach.
The goal is to provide the Board of Education and the community with a clearer understanding of what is possible, what each option may cost, and how different approaches could meet the district's educational and operational needs over time.
Importantly, the district has not made a final decision regarding a future construction project or the specific configuration of its schools. The current work is intended to develop realistic, informed options for consideration. Representatives from Garmann Miller will present their findings and preliminary facility options at the December 3, 2026, Board of Education work session at 6 p.m. The presentation will include an overview of the options being studied, preliminary cost estimates, potential phasing considerations, and the opportunities and challenges associated with each approach.
Next Steps and Opportunities for Community Input
Following the December presentation, the Board of Education anticipates selecting a preferred facility option in January, informed by the feasibility study, projected costs, and the district’s long-term educational and financial priorities. Once the Board has determined the project's direction, the district will invite residents, families, staff, and community stakeholders to participate in the next phase of planning. These opportunities will focus on gathering feedback regarding building design, site layout, functionality, shared spaces, and other important elements that will shape the final project. While the Board will establish the overall scope and financial framework, community input will help ensure the facilities reflect the needs and priorities of our students, staff, and Independence community.
"We heard our community in May, and we recognize the importance of taking a thoughtful and financially responsible approach to our facility needs," said Superintendent Kelli Cogan. "The needs at our primary and middle schools have not gone away, but we also recognize that there may be different ways to address them. By exploring a phased approach, prioritizing our most pressing needs, and considering how we can preserve and improve existing spaces, we hope to develop a plan that is both educationally sound and responsive to our community."
Cogan emphasized that the district's responsibility extends beyond simply determining whether to renovate or build new facilities. "Ultimately, our responsibility is to ensure that every student in Independence has access to safe, modern, and high-quality learning environments. That includes addressing the significant needs at our primary and middle schools, maintaining and protecting the investment our community has made in Independence High School, and establishing sustainable plans to address deferred maintenance across the district. Whatever direction we ultimately pursue, our facilities should reflect the pride our community has in its schools and our commitment to providing an exceptional educational experience for every student."
December 3 Board of Education Work Session
Date: Thursday, December 3, 2026
Time: 6 p.m.
Location: Independence High School Media Center
Presentation: Garmann Miller Facility Feasibility Study and Preliminary Options
Independence Local Schools remains committed to transparency, community engagement, and responsible long-term planning. The district recognizes that addressing aging facilities will require difficult decisions and meaningful financial investments. However, by continuing to evaluate alternatives, listening to community feedback, and considering both immediate priorities and long-term needs, the district hopes to identify a sustainable path forward.
The goal remains unchanged: to provide facilities that support outstanding educational opportunities, protect the community's investment, and reflect the high expectations and pride that define Independence Local Schools.

